LL/PSL: Yes/Jethro Tull With You There to Perpetually Change

[kath]

"A Time for Everything?"

This another track I think Steven Wilson has cleaned up too much

There needs to be some murkiness here!




.

i will not indulge this.

i will be in yer yard. with weaponry. just sayin. (damn, still need to renew my passport.)

by the way, i love ian's lyrics, i do.

[C]

FEEEEEEEEEEEDBACK

A Barre moment for sure (the whole song) .

Awesome!




.

[Charlie O.]

Inside - ditto re: clean up

A fantastic track

[The tubs aren't right either]





.

yup

[Six String]

Inside - ditto re: clean up

A fantastic track

[The tubs aren't right either]





.

The tubs sound like they are in another county!

[LMG]

Inside needs to be later in the album. It is perfect here.

[kath]

can yew cook, can you sewww, i don't reallly know

[Spock!]

"Inside" - trance-inducing song

It's delightful, sounds a little Indian in places. Want to add my own percussion.

[Six String]

Got no money coming in
But I can’t be sad.

[LMG]

The Wilson Collector's edition is great if you can play it - you can play the original mix from the DVD, I am doing so now.

[Charlie O.]

Inside needs to be later in the album. It is perfect here.

It kind of is.

And yet "Teacher" sounds so right coming after "A Time...".

[kath]

oooooooooooof

[Charlie O.]

Nice organ

[C]

"A Time for Everything?"

This another track I think Steven Wilson has cleaned up too much

There needs to be some murkiness here!




.

i will not indulge this.

i will be in yer yard. with weaponry. just sayin. (damn, still need to renew my passport.)

by the way, i love ian's lyrics, i do.

Wilson has done a fantastic job with virtually everything else by Tull and others

But Benefit benefitted [groan] for an element of murkiness in places and the clean up has, for me, has removed that to its detriment

Just a personal view - I may be speaking solo.

It's when you know an album backwards and then you hear it again and think - why?




.

[Charlie O.]

More backwards-ness

[C]

Play in Time!!!

A monster of a track

Fierce and fiery


.

[Six String]

Nice organ

*tucks it back in his trousers*

[Charlie O.]

Freak out, baby!

[C]

Inside - ditto re: clean up

A fantastic track

[The tubs aren't right either]





.

The tubs sound like they are in another county!

Yep!

But don't tell kath



.

[C]

THIS IS A BELTER!!




.

[Charlie O.]

Martin really shines on this album - more than usual. It isn't just the riffs, but... everything.