The Seekers California Dreamin' 1966
- GoogaMooga
- custodian of oldies
- Posts: 30379
- Joined: 28 Sep 2010, 05:23
- Location: Denmark
The Seekers California Dreamin' 1966
Presenting to you, the incomparable Judith Durham:
"When the desert comes, people will be sad; just as Cannery Row was sad when all the pilchards were caught and canned and eaten." - John Steinbeck
- Matt Wilson
- Psychedelic Cowpunk
- Posts: 32527
- Joined: 16 Jul 2003, 20:18
- Location: Edge of a continent
Re: The Seekers California Dreamin' 1966
Why anyone other than the Mamas and Papas bothers to sing that song is beyond me.
-
- Posts: 2340
- Joined: 05 Jul 2017, 23:05
Re: The Seekers California Dreamin' 1966
Matt Wilson wrote:Why anyone other than the Mamas and Papas bothers to sing that song is beyond me.
You don't like the Beach Boys version? I really like it.
- GoogaMooga
- custodian of oldies
- Posts: 30379
- Joined: 28 Sep 2010, 05:23
- Location: Denmark
Re: The Seekers California Dreamin' 1966
Matt Wilson wrote:Why anyone other than the Mamas and Papas bothers to sing that song is beyond me.
Mamas and the Papas is the definitive version, to be sure, but I have time for other versions. I think the following recordings hold their own:
Seekers (Judith Durham, the finest voice in pop/folk)
Beach Boys (superior guitar intro)
José Feliciano
Wes Montgomery (jazz instrumental)
Would I swap Mamas & the Papas for Judith Durham? No, but I'm glad it's there.
"When the desert comes, people will be sad; just as Cannery Row was sad when all the pilchards were caught and canned and eaten." - John Steinbeck
- Rorschach
- Posts: 4120
- Joined: 02 Jun 2008, 12:43
- Location: The north side of my town faces east, and the east faces south
Re: The Seekers California Dreamin' 1966
I quite like Georgy Girl, though I suspect it's more out of nostalgia than anything else, but I don't much like the Seekers outside of that.
Judith Durham has a fine, sweet voice but I don't think she can actually sing. Sure, she hits the notes but her delivery is so sterile to my ears that she may as well be sight reading the song without ever having heard it before.
The Mamas and Papas sound like they actually really are missing California while the Seekers just sound like they're singing a song about missing California.
Judith Durham has a fine, sweet voice but I don't think she can actually sing. Sure, she hits the notes but her delivery is so sterile to my ears that she may as well be sight reading the song without ever having heard it before.
The Mamas and Papas sound like they actually really are missing California while the Seekers just sound like they're singing a song about missing California.
Bugger off.
- GoogaMooga
- custodian of oldies
- Posts: 30379
- Joined: 28 Sep 2010, 05:23
- Location: Denmark
Re: The Seekers California Dreamin' 1966
Rorschach wrote:I quite like Georgy Girl, though I suspect it's more out of nostalgia than anything else, but I don't much like the Seekers outside of that.
Judith Durham has a fine, sweet voice but I don't think she can actually sing. Sure, she hits the notes but her delivery is so sterile to my ears that she may as well be sight reading the song without ever having heard it before.
The Mamas and Papas sound like they actually really are missing California while the Seekers just sound like they're singing a song about missing California.
Seekers' version lacks the edge that Mamas & the Papas has got, but to claim that Judith Durham can't sing is laughable. You are the first person I have ever come across who says Judith Durham can't sing, but you are of course in your good right to have that opinion.
"When the desert comes, people will be sad; just as Cannery Row was sad when all the pilchards were caught and canned and eaten." - John Steinbeck
-
- Posts: 2340
- Joined: 05 Jul 2017, 23:05
Re: The Seekers California Dreamin' 1966
Rorschach wrote:I quite like Georgy Girl, though I suspect it's more out of nostalgia than anything else, but I don't much like the Seekers outside of that.
Judith Durham has a fine, sweet voice but I don't think she can actually sing. Sure, she hits the notes but her delivery is so sterile to my ears that she may as well be sight reading the song without ever having heard it before.
The Mamas and Papas sound like they actually really are missing California while the Seekers just sound like they're singing a song about missing California.
As a general rule the Seeker harmonies were what worked, though arguably no more than other such groups eg the Springfields.
Meanwhile the best Seekers tracks are often the ones were JD is not singing lead, like the Wreck of the Old 97 or With my swag all on my shoulder.
- GoogaMooga
- custodian of oldies
- Posts: 30379
- Joined: 28 Sep 2010, 05:23
- Location: Denmark
Re: The Seekers California Dreamin' 1966
Judith Durham is Australia's greatest gift to mankind.
"When the desert comes, people will be sad; just as Cannery Row was sad when all the pilchards were caught and canned and eaten." - John Steinbeck
- Darkness_Fish
- Posts: 7800
- Joined: 27 Jul 2015, 09:58
Re: The Seekers California Dreamin' 1966
I'm with Rorschach here, she sounds like she's reading a takeaway menu. Technically she might be great, but there's no emotion whatsoever, no connection to the song.
Like fast-moving clouds casting shadows against a hillside, the melody-loop shuddered with a sense of the sublime, the awful unknowable majesty of the world.
- GoogaMooga
- custodian of oldies
- Posts: 30379
- Joined: 28 Sep 2010, 05:23
- Location: Denmark
Re: The Seekers California Dreamin' 1966
Darkness_Fish wrote:I'm with Rorschach here, she sounds like she's reading a takeaway menu. Technically she might be great, but there's no emotion whatsoever, no connection to the song.
I agree with both of you that she is not connecting, but there are other yardsticks to go by, such as purity of voice. I am still baffled that one would make the claim that she can't sing. The timbre and perfection of Judith's voice is unequalled in pop, IMO.
"When the desert comes, people will be sad; just as Cannery Row was sad when all the pilchards were caught and canned and eaten." - John Steinbeck
- Rorschach
- Posts: 4120
- Joined: 02 Jun 2008, 12:43
- Location: The north side of my town faces east, and the east faces south
Re: The Seekers California Dreamin' 1966
GoogaMooga wrote:Darkness_Fish wrote:I'm with Rorschach here, she sounds like she's reading a takeaway menu. Technically she might be great, but there's no emotion whatsoever, no connection to the song.
I agree with both of you that she is not connecting, but there are other yardsticks to go by, such as purity of voice. I am still baffled that one would make the claim that she can't sing. The timbre and perfection of Judith's voice is unequalled in pop, IMO.
What I'm saying is that there's more to singing than just having a good voice. You could have the greatest physique in the world but not be any good at a given sport because you don't have the technique or some other factor. If you don't have the complete range of required skills you won't be a great footballer.
Sure, Judith Durham has a pure voice, she can hit the notes, she does it effortlessly but, in my opinion, she can't express any feeling in a song, ergo, she can't sing.
Bugger off.
- GoogaMooga
- custodian of oldies
- Posts: 30379
- Joined: 28 Sep 2010, 05:23
- Location: Denmark
Re: The Seekers California Dreamin' 1966
Rorschach wrote:Sure, Judith Durham has a pure voice, she can hit the notes, she does it effortlessly but, in my opinion, she can't express any feeling in a song, ergo, she can't sing.
Well, she is adored by millions of fans the world over, she has perfect pitch, she does a lot more than just hitting the notes. Just read the comments on youtube, they go on forever, singing her praises. Perhaps The Seekers are just too old hat, too square for you.
We'll just have to disagree on her ability to sing. I have never heard a purer voice. Maybe she felt a bit on unknown territory, with the Mamas & Papas million-seller released the same year. And with her background as an Australian, she deferred to the American folk-pop group, who were on home ground, so to speak. Yes, I prefer the Mamas & the Papas version, but man, am I glad I discovered this video today! Even the promo itself, with the Qantas 707 is wonderful, just wonderful. We'll never experience such times again.
Last edited by GoogaMooga on 24 Nov 2021, 15:22, edited 1 time in total.
"When the desert comes, people will be sad; just as Cannery Row was sad when all the pilchards were caught and canned and eaten." - John Steinbeck
- Neige
- Alpine Numpty
- Posts: 18128
- Joined: 17 Jul 2003, 11:11
- Location: On 2 oz of plastic with a hole in the middle (of nowhere)
Re: The Seekers California Dreamin' 1966
Matt Wilson wrote:Why anyone other than the Mamas and Papas bothers to sing that song is beyond me.
I agree, but with emphasis on "sing", because this is killer!
Thumpety-thump beats plinkety-plonk every time. - Rayge
- naughty boy
- hounds people off the board
- Posts: 20266
- Joined: 24 Apr 2007, 23:21
Re: The Seekers California Dreamin' 1966
Matt 'interesting' Wilson wrote:So I went from looking at the "I'm a Man" riff, to showing how the rave up was popular for awhile.
- Matt Wilson
- Psychedelic Cowpunk
- Posts: 32527
- Joined: 16 Jul 2003, 20:18
- Location: Edge of a continent
Re: The Seekers California Dreamin' 1966
And John keeps reading them!
- GoogaMooga
- custodian of oldies
- Posts: 30379
- Joined: 28 Sep 2010, 05:23
- Location: Denmark
Re: The Seekers California Dreamin' 1966
Yeah, plus ca change. I know what is BCB friendly and what is not, but the prog/rockist stance only is BORING.
"When the desert comes, people will be sad; just as Cannery Row was sad when all the pilchards were caught and canned and eaten." - John Steinbeck
- Rorschach
- Posts: 4120
- Joined: 02 Jun 2008, 12:43
- Location: The north side of my town faces east, and the east faces south
Re: The Seekers California Dreamin' 1966
GoogaMooga wrote:Yeah, plus ca change. I know what is BCB friendly and what is not, but the prog/rockist stance only is BORING.
That's just your opinion though. A lot of people find prog and/or rock music very entertaining. In fact so much so that one of them set up this forum specifically to talk about such things.
What is now BCB friendly is a hard thing to fathom, but I've never had the impression that you had even the faintest inkling of what was BCB friendly and what was not in your early years on here.
Bugger off.
- GoogaMooga
- custodian of oldies
- Posts: 30379
- Joined: 28 Sep 2010, 05:23
- Location: Denmark
Re: The Seekers California Dreamin' 1966
Rorschach wrote:GoogaMooga wrote:Yeah, plus ca change. I know what is BCB friendly and what is not, but the prog/rockist stance only is BORING.
That's just your opinion though. A lot of people find prog and/or rock music very entertaining. In fact so much so that one of them set up this forum specifically to talk about such things.
What is now BCB friendly is a hard thing to fathom, but I've never had the impression that you had even the faintest inkling of what was BCB friendly and what was not in your early years on here.
Oh, I think I knew. Coan made bloody sure I knew. I liked to challenge the canon, and took the blows.
"When the desert comes, people will be sad; just as Cannery Row was sad when all the pilchards were caught and canned and eaten." - John Steinbeck
- GoogaMooga
- custodian of oldies
- Posts: 30379
- Joined: 28 Sep 2010, 05:23
- Location: Denmark
Re: The Seekers California Dreamin' 1966
It would be nice if there was a forum that covered ALL music, but they don't exist.
"When the desert comes, people will be sad; just as Cannery Row was sad when all the pilchards were caught and canned and eaten." - John Steinbeck
- naughty boy
- hounds people off the board
- Posts: 20266
- Joined: 24 Apr 2007, 23:21
Re: The Seekers California Dreamin' 1966
GoogaMooga wrote:Rorschach wrote:GoogaMooga wrote:Yeah, plus ca change. I know what is BCB friendly and what is not, but the prog/rockist stance only is BORING.
That's just your opinion though. A lot of people find prog and/or rock music very entertaining. In fact so much so that one of them set up this forum specifically to talk about such things.
What is now BCB friendly is a hard thing to fathom, but I've never had the impression that you had even the faintest inkling of what was BCB friendly and what was not in your early years on here.
Oh, I think I knew. Coan made bloody sure I knew. I liked to challenge the canon, and took the blows.
Matt 'interesting' Wilson wrote:So I went from looking at the "I'm a Man" riff, to showing how the rave up was popular for awhile.