The Modernist wrote:Dr. E. PLATE wrote:The Modernist wrote:Bowie used to be quite underappreciated on BCB. I used to feel in a minority defending him back then. These days we're more balanced in our view of him.
As for NY I think he offers something quite unique and valuable, I get the love from that viewpoint, but I don't think he's a particular strong songwriter.
I think he's every bit as good a songwriter as Bowie.
I think I'd struggle to name 10 NY songs that have really impacted upon the wider public consciousness.
Me too. But I'd be able to name 10 NY songs that show he's a very good songwriter!