PP2017 Round 5 Match 7 *joels344 10- gash 7*

[never/ever]

A

Kayo Dot - Wayfarer





B

The Byrds - Chestnut Mare

[algroth]

Very neat match. A isn't necessarily my favorite from Choirs of the Eye, but still great stuff. And some folky Byrds is always welcome. In this case I'm pretty torn between the two, but for the stronger prog factor I'll give it to A.

[Loki]

'She'll be just like a wife', Roger? Um, okaaay.....


Like Al said, for the Prog factor~

[joels344]

A

[Osgood]

I found A terribly boring. Is B prog? I wouldn't say so, and I don't think it is especially good either. Another disappointing match this round

abstain

[toomanyhatz]

B is not only a very overrated song, it's not prog by any stretch of the imagination. Unless fitting one rule ("it's over five minutes!") is enough, but I would argue it's not.

A is nothing special, but at least it got the memo.

[fange]

B

[Rayge]

I like B

[Jumper K]

A is proggy B isn't. A is bunkum. B isn't.
Its a draw.
Going to vote B.

[Hightea]

I almost picked a Kayo Dot song but couldn't decide on one. NIce one here love the influences and interesting places this song goes.

Ah Chestnut Mare one of my favorite Byrds songs. Yes its a better song than A but this is a prog contest not any song. this round is starting to bore me with all the non prog songs.


A

[C]

A






.

[Hugh]

Abstain.

[Lord Rother]

I love prog but A is too waily and drifty for me.

I love B even though it ain't prog.

B

[kath]

nuthing against B, which is a fine byrds track. i dig it very much.

... but i thought A was amazing. obviously, i need to hear more of this stuff. forfucquinsooth.

[never/ever]

A

[trans-chigley express]

A

[Nancy]

[Neige]

B, surprisingly

[clive gash]

Not Prog B

[Good Night Austin, Texas]

B