Copehead wrote:I still don't really understand why the Manics produce more extreme responses than say Muse, but they do and that makes it interesting to discuss them.
You seem to have mistaken what you say about the Manic Street Preachers with
the Manic Street Preachers.
Frankly that is rubbish. It doesn't even mean anything.
I laid out a fairly innocuous case for them and let the vitriol flow.
8 pages now.
A thread on Muse would garner one page, generally favourable.
For some reason people seem compelled to share their hatred of MSP in great detail., it is fascinating.
They are a pretty pedestrian second-division plodrock outfit who no-one really particularly has any strong feelings about.
Like most people who hate them you appear to have heard very little of their music.
And this very thread shows your point to be risible.
You seem to have made a BCB career out of being spectacularly and comically wrong in just about everything you write, good to see you aren't having an off day here.
Who writes a post on page 8 of a thread saying no one is interested in the thread, you are a hoot.
The silly things you say about them, however, do provoke responses.
Basically all I said is I really like the Manics, the judgement that this is silly and the undeniable compulsion to comment on that is all yours.
And your idea of "interesting" matches your boofer-loofer kitschmensch idea of what constitutes decent music.
Thank you, I think you have all the musical taste of a ten year old dish rag as well.