70s Cup Grand Final Match 4 *Loki 11- Ranking Ted 22*

[algroth]

I think I'm one of the biggest proponents in this board of the idea that a jam can be just as great a track and as valid a choice for these things as a great traditional song... But it's got to have something of interest going for it. A feels utterly mechanical and lifeless, a group of musicians going through the motions and arriving nowhere as the video simply fades out. B actually has a semblance of a hook or some element of interest, but even when it becomes an extended jam it's more interesting and infectious at it than the former. It's the clear winner here.

[harvey k-tel]

B is nice, but just a touch to smoooth for my liking. A seems kinda slight by comparison, though - and I have to ask: why did they have all those microphones on the stage?

B, I guess.

[GoogaMooga]

I like the tightness and professionalism of A, right down to the siren-like Nutbush keyboards. It shuffles along so assured of itself, while B meanders a bit. Kendricks' soprano is put to much better use on something tender like Just My Imagination. A

[Neige]

Too much clavinet and synth on A, so it'll be B for me.

[Belle Lettre]

B

[mantochanga]

A

[Osgood]

I surrender to the groove of

A

[Count Machuki]

another toughie

B

[pcqgod]

A

[Hightea]

B

[joels344]

B here. There's at least some thump to it.

[Jumper K]

A. I can't muster any ire against these 2.

[clive gash]

B.

[never/ever]

I'll have the staccato porn of


A

[never/ever]

Loki 11

Ranking Ted 22