PP2017 Round 6 Match 3 *Jumper K 7- Osgood 7*

[never/ever]

A

King Crimson - Indiscipline





B

John McLaughlin – Marbles

[Good Night Austin, Texas]

B

[Hightea]

Was shocked KC played Indiscipline the other night in Red Bank, NJ. This shows how much I miss Belew in the new KC lineup. Also as great as Pat and Gavin were Bruford kicks ass here. So remember this tour.

Love Marles - Larry Young organ with Buddy Miles on drums this is a great jam piece.

tough call here I'll give it to A because I saw them this week

[toomanyhatz]

I like that era of Crimson a lot. There's a bit of pseudo new wavy 'quirkiness,' but I find it good-spirited - almost with an edge of self-parody to it. And Fripp's professorial bent will always present a amusing counterpart should it get to be too much.

McLaughlin's playing is great, and I love the aggressive tone of the whole thing, but Buddy Miles's hamfistedness comes damn close to ruining it for me.

A in a close call.

[Loki]

[Osgood]

I love this KC lineup and how much Adrian Belew contributed to make things work. This track is great though I could live without the spoken parts.

Marbles is an all-time fave of mine in the Santana /Miles version and only recently I came accross the original, and it is certainly better.

Tough, but B

[fange]

B

[Hugh]

B

[never/ever]

A

[Jumper K]

This is more like it. My favourite KC period. This is batshit bonkers.
B is unlistenable wannabe Jazz toss.
A.

[C]

B





.

[trans-chigley express]

B

[kath]

that mclaughlin really gets up and goes. however, i am a true freak for this era crimson. wickedly fantastic. i am alll over it.

[algroth]

Good tracks, both of them. A has the edge for me here.

[Neige]

No Belew backlash then? Might be a mood thing, but I actively dislike Indiscipline, and B isn't much better, sorry.

[Nancy]

B really gets up a head of steam in the second half, but I can't vote against

[never/ever]

Jumper K 7

Osgood 7