All-purpose Cup comment thread

[Penk!]

A lot of indie around. There don't seem to be as many lists that really work for me this year, but a few of those that do have made it through already, which is nice.

Only seen a couple of themed lists so far but perhaps I'm not spotting some of them.

'Rocks Off' is popular, isn't it?

[The Modernist]

There's been a lot of indie this year.
I thought the standard was pretty high but the last three days have left me quite deflated!
Hopefully we'll get a better day tomorrow.

[Bungo the Mungo]

You two are the pickiest fuckers around!

[McBastard]

Some people are complaining that they don't discover anything interesting or new during the cup, but refuse to vote for lists that aren't full of songs they already know.

[Penk!]

The prog lists seem to be picking up a bit more support this time round. Have they had another recruitment drive?

[McBastard]

Only seen a couple of themed lists so far but perhaps I'm not spotting some of them.

Are you in favour of themed lists? Do the prog ones count?

[The Modernist]

You two are the pickiest fuckers around!

I tend to praise more than you!
You're too busy complaining how obscure everything is.
I haven't been so positive in the last few days though, but I think that's been the case with many people's reactions.

[Penk!]

Only seen a couple of themed lists so far but perhaps I'm not spotting some of them.

Are you in favour of themed lists? Do the prog ones count?

I don't really see the point in themed lists. They're not going to get anywhere in the Cup and you're not really putting your taste on the line for anyone to see. You're just showing that you can put together a list of songs that are somehow connected.

I think the prog ones count as they do seem to be a recurrent thing. I get the impression that some people do them just to prove some nebulous point (hence the annual appearance of "The Prog Bastard" [this year calling themselves "The Genius of Prog"], who somehow seems to get around the usual no-aliases rule).

[Jeff K]

You two are the pickiest fuckers around!

Well, now we know that one of the lists with Rocks Off is John's.

[clive gash]

Funkadelic seem to be quite poplular, so too Deerhunter.

the last three days have left me quite deflated!

BCburnout has set in early, it's been quite difficult to choose. A lack of aesthetic consistency, or even personality in many lists.

[Bungo the Mungo]

You two are the pickiest fuckers around!

I tend to praise more than you!
You're too busy complaining how obscure everything is.
I haven't been so positive in the last few days though, but I think that's been the case with many people's reactions.

I do think there are a lot of obscure choices. It interests me rather than pisses me off - I wonder what the purpose of the Cup is, what people are voting for, what people who put together lists of unfamiliar (to others) songs are actually saying.

I also find the way the lists look has an influence on the way people vote. We're basing our decisions on reading lists and not hearing collections of songs, to some extent.

[Goat Boy]

Not much for me to get excited about I'm afraid. Wildly uneven lists mostly. Ho hum.

I fear for myself this year.

[dgs]

Funkadelic seem to be quite poplular, so too Deerhunter.

the last three days have left me quite deflated!

BCburnout has set in early, it's been quite difficult to choose. A lack of aesthetic consistency, or even personality in many lists.

Bollocks

Bleep summed it up in another thread 10 good songs are 10 good songs, irrespective of theme, diversity or narrowness.

Not all good songs need to be like a fine wine; aged or of a certain grape/region.

[The Modernist]

I also find the way the lists look has an influence on the way people vote. We're basing our decisions on reading lists and not hearing collections of songs, to some extent.

I'm doing that more this year I must admit. I'll probably pay closer attention to some of the choices when its 1 v 1.

[clive gash]

Funkadelic seem to be quite poplular, so too Deerhunter.

the last three days have left me quite deflated!

BCburnout has set in early, it's been quite difficult to choose. A lack of aesthetic consistency, or even personality in many lists.

Bollocks

Bleep summed it up in another thread 10 good songs are 10 good songs, irrespective of theme, diversity or narrowness.

Not all good songs need to be like a fine wine; aged or of a certain grape/region.

No, they need to be good - where have they been hiding then?

[Count Machuki]

The prog lists seem to be picking up a bit more support this time round. Have they had another recruitment drive?

Having had a taste of democracy in their own Cup, they long to continue having their voices heard in a larger context.

That's my theory, anyway. They've got Cup fever.

[dgs]

No, they need to be good - where have they been hiding then?

They are all there, in plain sight.

Please explain what Bcburnout means? Sounds like some sort of code for an approved list rather than an actual cross comparison of the songs listed on their merits. No one can truly claim to be able to judge as no one has actually heard all the songs or is able to compare them line for line.

Pisses me off no end that something out of the "canon" is instantly dismissed as being a poor bcb choice or not good enough.

[Goat Boy]

Pisses me off no end that something out of the "canon" is instantly dismissed as being a poor bcb choice or not good enough.

Because it's been picked a hundred times before. What's the point? We could all do that.

[The Modernist]

I just think there's been some poor stuff in the last few days, it's not really to do with the canon though. If anything you feel some are trying too hard to be different and just not pulling it off.

[Bungo the Mungo]

So we pick stuff that no-one has heard?