Goat Boy wrote:The Modernist wrote:But it was was easy to recognise which Balbao's list was. I had a real quandary in that I really liked both, but I think it's in the spirit of the competition to judge the new five.
Do we really want whole lists being repeated?
I don't think it was actually. They both coulda been Balboa's hence my confusion. I just want the extra five to correspond to the original A and B lists, that's all.
I assumed it was his because of Steely Dan. I don't know why it was originally decided to ascribe the A and B's at random, I suppose the idea is to judge the new fives on their own merits. But I wouldn't have any objection if it was decided to keep the lists to the letter they had in their original tie.