Strider wrote:This is my first BCB Cup and its really is a bit of silly fun don't you think. What is interesting for me to observe is the number of people whose basis for voting against a list is that it is too "canonical". If songs are great they are great despite how many people and critics say they are. No matter how many people say that "Rain" or "Gimme Shelter" or "Like A Rolling Stone" are great songs does not make them any less great and the converse is also true. What is one man's greatness is another man's mediocrity, I suppose. It just bothers me to see the number of folks voting against lists where they state that they like the artists and songs listed but then say its too "canonical". Too me, that just does not make sense.