Do proggers like this?

[Rorschach]

I can never get to grips with what exactly constitutes prog, except I seem to hate nearly everything that gets called that. Sometimes I find myself idly wondering whether something non-prog cannon I'm listening to might be considered prog and whether proggers would like it.
Here's an example. It's very pretty, has minimal (and banal) lyrics and turns well proggy just after the 2 minute mark.

What do you think?

[never/ever]

It's pretty good, ii like the way it starts and how the break all of a sudden recalls the Heavy Metal-movie's 70's psych-rock vibe. It's a shame it falls apart thematically at the second part.

Guess you could call it progressive but it would be prog-lite at the highest.

[Rorschach]

Guess you could call it progressive but it would be prog-lite at the highest.

Damn. Back to the drawing board.

Glad you liked some of it though.

[C]

Proggers....?

Prog goons - please Tym!

[Rorschach]

Proggers?

Prog goons - please!

Sorry C. I'm never too sure whether an outsider like me is allowed to use the term. I shall try to remember in future.

Now listen to the bloody track and comment on it!

[Purgatory Brite]

I liked it. Reminds me slightly of Tame Impala recent album.

[C]

Sorry C. I'm never too sure whether an outsider like me is allowed to use the term. I shall try to remember in future.

You're not an outsider Tym lad - you have broad church prog elements...





.

[Rorschach]

I liked it. Reminds me slightly of Tame Impala recent album.

Ooh. Interesting comparison. I shall have to give that another listen.

[C]

I quite enjoyed the first 30 seconds then it became repetitive.

After 2 minutes it was a dog's breakfast

Irritating vocals

0.5/10






.

[C]

What about the views of other goons.....?




.

[Diamond Dog]

What about the views of other goons.....?




.

If it's come from Tym, it's shite.

[Spock!]

A bit too bland/polished for me.

[Lord Rother]

A bit too bland/polished for me.

Yeah, I’ll go with that. Not really my bag.

(I do get the Tame Impala reference.)

[The Slider]

I thought it ponderous and indecisive and lacking in pretty much everything - though the first minute or so had a nice relaxed vibe, it never went anywhere. Then when it did I wished it hadn't. Or at least that it had gone somewhere else.

[Rorschach]

I thought it ponderous and indecisive and lacking in pretty much everything - though the first minute or so had a nice relaxed vibe, it never went anywhere. Then when it did I wished it hadn't. Or at least that it had gone somewhere else.

Pretty much what I thought. That’s why I thought maybe you prog goons would like it.
Looks like I haven’t quite nailed it.

[Neige]

I quite liked most of it apart from the vocals, but it's ultimately very forgettable