Goat Boy wrote:The whole broad church nonsense has been a pernicious BCB con job from the very beginning, perpetrated by the high priest of BCB PROG, C and his more fawning onanistic acolytes for their ongoing Prog Corner circle jerks.
hence Krautrock becomes "prog", hence Eno becomes "prog", hence anything C likes becomes a bit "prog".
You've missed the actual point. Carlsson doesn't actually like Prog, evidenced by his oft repreated claim that not one note of music released after 1974 has any merit. His so-called handful of decent bands since 74 is a deception, most of them are average or mediocre. I think he has a dysfunctional attitude to music, he instantly dismisses any music from outside of his comfort zone as "derivative claptrap" which show a ridiculous intolerance on his part. I found, to my cost, that he doesn't like music only noise.