SG vs TWotM

Do talk back

?

SG
16
46%
TWofM
19
54%
 
Total votes: 35

User avatar
ORORORO
hounds people off the board
Posts: 17137
Joined: 24 Apr 2007, 23:21
Location: pursued by the enraged queen

SG vs TWotM

Postby ORORORO » 09 Mar 2018, 16:27



Jimbo wrote:My brain is packed with info

User avatar
Quaco
F R double E
Posts: 46670
Joined: 16 Jul 2003, 19:41

Re: SG vs TWotM

Postby Quaco » 09 Mar 2018, 16:53

Is this a trick question?
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

User avatar
Goat Boy
Bogarting the joint
Posts: 31822
Joined: 20 Mar 2007, 12:11
Location: In the perfumed garden

Re: SG vs TWotM

Postby Goat Boy » 09 Mar 2018, 17:39

I listened to the Big Star one again and thought, fuck, that's great!

And then I listened to Whole of the Moon and very quickly I started to get a wee lump in my throat and then I thought about the lass and I was almost on the verge of tears! It's a great record. I've always had a soft spot for it.

So Waterboys then
Diamond Dog wrote:Everyone else hates us.

Fuck you all.

We won.


The Modernist wrote:Griff writes the best political posts.

User avatar
Harvey K-Tel
Long Player
Posts: 39670
Joined: 16 Jul 2003, 23:20
Location: 1220 on your AM dial

Re: SG vs TWotM

Postby Harvey K-Tel » 09 Mar 2018, 17:44

As much as I love 'September Gurls' (and it was the very first Big Star song I ever heard), I get the same visceral response to 'Whole of the Moon' as GB does. It's part of my DNA.
If you've got nothing to do, don't do it here.

User avatar
ORORORO
hounds people off the board
Posts: 17137
Joined: 24 Apr 2007, 23:21
Location: pursued by the enraged queen

Re: SG vs TWotM

Postby ORORORO » 09 Mar 2018, 18:07

I agree with my right honourable friends.
Jimbo wrote:My brain is packed with info

User avatar
ORORORO
hounds people off the board
Posts: 17137
Joined: 24 Apr 2007, 23:21
Location: pursued by the enraged queen

Re: SG vs TWotM

Postby ORORORO » 09 Mar 2018, 18:14

Quaco wrote:Is this a trick question?


No! Why do you ask?
Jimbo wrote:My brain is packed with info

Positive Passion
Posts: 564
Joined: 05 Jul 2017, 23:05

Re: SG vs TWotM

Postby Positive Passion » 09 Mar 2018, 18:29

A new low.

User avatar
LeBaron
Diamond Geezer
Posts: 42615
Joined: 18 Jul 2003, 05:38
Location: Impregnable Citadel of Technicality

Re: SG vs TWotM

Postby LeBaron » 09 Mar 2018, 18:37

In my world there’s Strawberry Fields/Penny Lane/Day Tripper/Paperback Writer and Good Vibrations. Then there’s September Gurls. Then there’s everything else. So, September Gurls for me, thanks.
Quaco wrote:Are you fucking high?

take5_d_shorterer wrote:If John Bonham simply didn't listen to enough Tommy Johnson or Blind Willie Mctell, that's his doing.

User avatar
yomptepi
BCB thumbscrew of Justice
Posts: 35036
Joined: 16 Jul 2003, 17:57
Location: well

Re: SG vs TWotM

Postby yomptepi » 09 Mar 2018, 18:40

The Waterboys are utterly shit.
Big Star are utterly brilliant.

End of.
You don't like me...do you?

User avatar
ORORORO
hounds people off the board
Posts: 17137
Joined: 24 Apr 2007, 23:21
Location: pursued by the enraged queen

Re: SG vs TWotM

Postby ORORORO » 09 Mar 2018, 19:07

I get that Big Star were a great band. I really do. There's such beauty in those melodies, they're essential in a way few bands match. I love them.

But if we're looking at these two songs - there's no competition as far as I'm concerned. 'September Gurls' is prime power-pop. It's sweet, it's pretty. But it doesn't take off.

That bit in 'The Whole Of The Moon' that starts at 2:15 - 'I spoke about wings', and the bass breaks out of its DUM DUM DUM to do this descending thing, and then the backing vocalist comes in - my God that's incredibly affecting. I don't get that kind of rush from many songs. By anyone.
Jimbo wrote:My brain is packed with info

User avatar
never/ever
Posts: 22131
Joined: 27 Jun 2008, 14:21
Location: Journeying through a burning brain

Re: SG vs TWotM

Postby never/ever » 09 Mar 2018, 19:39

I love Moon's keyboard riff that sounds like a wash of sound augmented by that lilting tune on the piano. And that it indeed gets a second wind halfway through and gets Mike Scott to another level in his vocal delivery- breathless stuff.
Up against another favorite, no less.
Ever notice that anyone going slower than you is an idiot, but anyone going faster is a maniac?."

George Carlin

User avatar
slightbreeze
Can I Get To Widnes?
Posts: 9759
Joined: 03 Sep 2003, 20:07
Location: facing the computer
Contact:

Re: SG vs TWotM

Postby slightbreeze » 09 Mar 2018, 19:47

The lyrics to Whole of the Moon are some of my favourites. ...ever

User avatar
jimboo
Posts: 6701
Joined: 29 Dec 2005, 17:43
Location: taking a foxy kind of stand

Re: SG vs TWotM

Postby jimboo » 09 Mar 2018, 20:36

There is better songs from the album than moon. Gurls by a country mile.

Big Star sound fey and tinny at first but the class soon surfaces , don't bang the drum is the real gem from this period , better lyrics too.
Goat Boy wrote:Oh, do fuck off, prog boy.

User avatar
George P. Smackers
Posts: 155
Joined: 11 Jun 2017, 23:18

Re: SG vs TWotM

Postby George P. Smackers » 09 Mar 2018, 20:42

Goat Boy wrote:I listened to the Big Star one again and thought, fuck, that's great!

And then I listened to Whole of the Moon and very quickly I started to get a wee lump in my throat and then I thought about the lass and I was almost on the verge of tears! It's a great record. I've always had a soft spot for it.

So Waterboys then


It's funny, I had the same reaction in reverse, sort of.

Something about "September Gurls" makes me tear up. It's got this melancholy going underneath that's hard to put your finger on. (I guess that's what people always say about Big Star. Power pop plus an undefinable layer of sadness.)

It's underneath the overt emotional stuff about "crying all the time." It's like that stuff is deliberately flat and bland to cover up the real sadness.

As for "Whole of the Moon," it's nice and all, and I like the deliberate and exaggerated melodrama and sentimentality, with the wings, stretch for the stars, wind at your heels, unicorns and camembert, oceans full of tears, and all that stuff. It's like a mock-up of overdone teenage emotion that's so silly, it's honest.

But it doesn't really get me. I was too old by then maybe. Asked the wife, she's all for the Waterboys, but she's a little younger, and the first time she heard "September Gurls" was the Bangles cover.

User avatar
The Red Heifer
Fucking Crackers
Posts: 14625
Joined: 31 Aug 2003, 01:28
Location: South Penriff
Contact:

Re: SG vs TWotM

Postby The Red Heifer » 09 Mar 2018, 20:49

Chalk me up on the "gets all swelled up inside when I hear The Whole Of The Moon" side
Wadesmith wrote:Why is it that when there's a 'What do you think of this?' post, it's always absolute cobblers?

User avatar
Davey the Fat Boy
Posts: 23443
Joined: 05 Jan 2006, 02:55
Location: Applebees

Re: SG vs TWotM

Postby Davey the Fat Boy » 09 Mar 2018, 21:16

The Waterboys track is basically a really good song performed well by a really good band. I get why it connects with people.

September Gurls is like a commercial for the power of pop music itself. Everything great that a good pop song can achieve is in that track.

I like The Whole of the Moon - but it is boxing outside of its weight here.
The opinions of this poster are subjective. That’s how opinions work.

Image

User avatar
Osgood
Posts: 1643
Joined: 28 Nov 2014, 09:48
Location: Madrid

Re: SG vs TWotM

Postby Osgood » 09 Mar 2018, 21:48

Voted for SG but it was close.
Nobody's ferpect.

User avatar
slightbreeze
Can I Get To Widnes?
Posts: 9759
Joined: 03 Sep 2003, 20:07
Location: facing the computer
Contact:

Re: SG vs TWotM

Postby slightbreeze » 09 Mar 2018, 23:49

Big Star are a second rate Teenage Fanclub

User avatar
ORORORO
hounds people off the board
Posts: 17137
Joined: 24 Apr 2007, 23:21
Location: pursued by the enraged queen

Re: SG vs TWotM

Postby ORORORO » 10 Mar 2018, 09:34

:)
Jimbo wrote:My brain is packed with info

User avatar
Pansy Puff
Posts: 8144
Joined: 22 Feb 2012, 21:10
Location: Under the watchful eye of the Clive police

Re: SG vs TWotM

Postby Pansy Puff » 10 Mar 2018, 09:37

Jesus fucking Christ what kind of world is it where people prefer the Whole of the Fucking Moon to September Gurls? Some fucking idiocy going on. Obviously it is Big Star. Listen to the Bear: the Waterboys are shit.
“He’s got the memory of an elephant ... and the trophy cabinet of one too.”